How to write a miscue analysis
Breaking Down Miscue Analysis The focus of the analysis should be on the unexpected or mismatched responses given by readers under evaluation.
Correction This is good!
What Do the Miscues Tell You? They argue that to conceptualize fluent reading as involving a word-for-word match promotes an inefficient or slow and labored approach to reading.
Omission When words are omitted, it may mean weaker visual tracking.
Miscue analysis cheat sheet
Correction This is good! The analysis will be inaccurate and would lose its value when conducted with an emerging reader but the information you gain may still be useful later on. Create a key for each miscue, and be sure to write the substitution or pre-correction above the word that was miscued so you can identify the pattern later. As Pinnell and Fountas point out, English is a language made up of several distinct languages and therefore is not phonetically regular. The interest lies on the miscues and how such miscues change, improve, or disrupt the meaning of the text in a material. Philosophy[ edit ] A key assumption of miscue analysis is that what readers do is neither accidental nor random. Poor readers, who have not developed this fluency skill, use such strategies as drawing from context in combination with looking at the picture or using only some of the letters in the words to predict a word that would make sense in context. Reading in this way, as all fluent readers do, allows for efficient reading. Photocopy the selection the student will read, use this to record the miscues. Effective reading involves the ability to self-monitor and apply strategies such as phonics, looking at pictures, skipping words, or using synonym substitutions when coming to words that the reader does not know. You will need a quiet place without interruptions, it can be very handy to record the child which provides you with an opportunity to listen to the passage more than once.
Studies[ edit ] Miscue analysis procedures include the collection and examination of a single and complete oral reading experience followed by a retelling. Insertion An insertion is a word s added by the child that is not in the text.
Miscue analysis msv
Reversal A child will reverse the order of the print or the word. Many screening tools will give you a "down and dirty" estimate of a child's reading proficiency but provide little useful information for designing appropriate interventions. The most basic contribution of miscue analysis to knowledge of the reading process is its demonstration that reading is an active, receptive language process. These procedures and standards for doing them are available in the books by Ken Goodman and co. The interest lies on the miscues and how such miscues change, improve, or disrupt the meaning of the text in a material. Continue Reading. Reading in this way, as all fluent readers do, allows for efficient reading. Only about half of the words readers encounter can be efficiently decoded using phonetic knowledge. Repetition The student repeats a word or portion of the text. Determine if the meaning of the passage is affected or not. The more you do an observation however, the easier the process gets. Studies[ edit ] Miscue analysis procedures include the collection and examination of a single and complete oral reading experience followed by a retelling. However, is the reader reading too fast?
Studies have shown that even good readers can correctly guess words in context only one out of ten times.
based on 34 review